Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta €805 million, roughly $887 million, over a Facebook feature on Android that scans a user's entire photo library to suggest posting from it. The regulator says the practice has run since 2023 and affects about 20 million Android users in Italy alone.
A Meta spokesperson told Reuters the company plans to appeal and called the fine disproportionate.
The problem, according to the Garante's November 14 statement, is how Facebook asks for access. A single Android permission covers the whole app and several unrelated functions, and the one notice users see beforehand never mentions that granting it will let Facebook suggest posts from the camera roll. The feature was switched on by default. Once granted, Facebook can keep reading the full photo library on an ongoing basis, and the regulator says neither users nor its own investigators can verify what actually gets used.
The Garante leaned on the ePrivacy Directive, which Italy has written into national law and which treats a smartphone as part of someone's private sphere. Under that rule, any access to what's stored on the device needs informed, specific consent, whether or not data leaves the phone. Meta argued Ireland's Data Protection Commission should have handled the case under the EU's one-stop-shop system. The Garante rejected that, pointing out the ePrivacy rules don't have a one-stop-shop mechanism the way GDPR does.
The size of the fine reflects the 20 million affected users, an earlier 2019 case against Meta in Italy, and what the authority called limited cooperation during the investigation. It works out to about 0.47 percent of Meta's global revenue. It's also not the company's first big European penalty: Ireland's regulator ordered Meta to pay €251 million in December 2024 over a 2018 Facebook security breach.
What has to change, and what doesn't
Meta now has 60 days to ask for separate, specific consent for the suggestion feature, explain in plain terms what it does, and turn it off by default, including for people who already granted gallery access under the old prompt.
The order only covers that specific suggestion feature and only applies in Italy. It does not touch AI training, which Meta says it doesn't do with this data. The Garante says it will look separately at a newer, opt-in version that processes the camera roll in the cloud using Meta AI to build collages and edits, which the company started rolling out in the EU and UK in April.
How to turn it off
For the basic version, open Facebook, go to Settings & Privacy, then Settings, and switch off camera roll suggestions there. Meta's help center says that setting applies across every device where Facebook has photo access. For a cleaner cut, go into Android's own Apps menu, find Facebook's permissions, and limit photo and video access to selected items or remove it outright.
Meta hasn't said whether it will make the same consent and default changes outside Italy while its appeal plays out.
TBFiled by The Tech Business Desk
Big tech, startups, earnings, regulation and policy — the decisions that shape the products.
More from this desk →
Be the first to comment
Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.