Skip to content
Trending
Tech Business2 min read

Sony Beats UK Lawsuit Claiming PlayStation Store Monopoly

London's Competition Appeal Tribunal rejected a consumer campaign's claim that Sony overcharged nine million UK PlayStation owners through its digital storefront.

By Market Close

The Tech Business Desk · (2 hours ago)

Reported fromoutlets, credited7
The PlayStation Store logo displayed on a PS5 console screen
The PlayStation Store logo displayed on a PS5 console screenPhoto via Kotaku

Sony has won a legal fight that once threatened to cost it billions. London's Competition Appeal Tribunal has thrown out a lawsuit claiming the PlayStation Store amounts to an illegal monopoly, ending a case that dragged on since 2022.

The case, filed on behalf of roughly nine million UK PlayStation owners by consumer advocate Alex Neill under the PlayStation You Owe Us campaign, argued Sony abused a dominant market position by blocking third-party storefronts from selling digital PS5 and PS4 games. That exclusivity, the campaign said, let Sony take a 30 percent cut of every digital sale without real competition, forcing players to pay too much for games and in-game purchases.

The tribunal disagreed. As reported by The Game Business, judges found the claim failed to establish that PlayStation's store setup breaks competition law. Their reasoning leaned on the idea that PlayStation doesn't compete in isolation. Xbox, Nintendo, PC storefronts and, for now, physical discs all count as alternatives, the tribunal said, which undercuts the monopoly argument. Judges also pointed to security risks from opening the console to outside stores, an argument that failed for Google when Epic Games sued over the Play Store. Here, it worked in Sony's favor.

A swinging price tag

The sum Sony was supposedly on the hook for moved around wildly as the case progressed. It started at $5.9 billion in 2022, climbed to $7.9 billion by 2023, then settled at $2.6 billion by this past May. None of that mattered once the tribunal ruled the underlying claim didn't hold up. Judges also said Neill's side never proved Sony's profits were excessive, a tough bar given that a 30 percent platform cut is roughly standard across the games industry, matching what Microsoft and Apple also charge.

Not over everywhere

Sony isn't in the clear globally. A near-identical case in California went the other way in May, when a jury ordered Sony to pay $7.8 billion over similar monopoly claims tied to the PlayStation Store. Sony is appealing that result. Separate cases are also pending in Holland, Portugal and Mexico, and nothing about Thursday's UK ruling binds how those play out.

The bigger backdrop here is Sony's own roadmap. Physical media on PlayStation is being phased out, and as that happens, the share of purchases running exclusively through Sony's own digital storefront, and through Sony's own cut, only grows. Thursday's ruling means British regulators aren't forcing that model open any time soon. Whether courts in Rotterdam, Lisbon or Mexico City see it the same way is still an open question, and each of those cases could land very differently for Sony's bottom line.

Reported from

How this story was made

Written by the Hitechreports desk from the reporting credited above, with facts attributed to their original publishers. We do not test devices ourselves; anything about performance, battery life or cameras comes from the outlets that did. Prices are as reported at the time of writing. Editorial policy · Report an error

What did you make of it?

Filed by The Tech Business Desk

Big tech, startups, earnings, regulation and policy — the decisions that shape the products.

More from this desk →

Be the first to comment

Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.