Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy launched last week as a $9.99 paid upgrade for existing Pikmin 4 owners on Nintendo Switch 2. It adds 4K visuals, a new challenge mode called Dandori Academy, and monthly batches of six timed courses — but players are calling it a repackaged, under-optimized stopgap.
Metacritic’s user score is “generally unfavourable”, with hundreds of negative reviews piling up since release. The backlash is rare for a Nintendo title, and unusually sharp for a first-party add-on. It’s not about the price. It’s about what’s inside, and what’s broken.
Players report loading times spiking to 30 seconds when exiting caves in story mode, a regression from the original Switch version. And the much-hyped Dandori Academy? Its first wave of levels mixes minor tweaks of existing campaign maps (rotated, recoloured, or reskinned) with recycled layouts from Pikmin 4’s base Dandori mode.
One reviewer on Metacritic wrote: “This is a big let down… My game had terrible loading times after getting this and they took forever. The new mode is boring and has copied levels.” Another called it “more of a downgrade than an upgrade”. Nintendo hasn’t commented publicly. No patch notes, no roadmap, no acknowledgment of the feedback, just silence so far.
This isn’t a review of Pikmin 4 itself. That game remains widely praised, IGN called it “arguably the best in the series”. But the Switch 2 Edition is being judged on its own terms: as a $10 commitment that delivers visual polish, slower performance, and questionable novelty. For fans who upgraded hardware expecting meaningful enhancements, not rehashed geometry and longer waits, the math doesn’t add up.
Dandori Academy’s structure compounds the frustration. Weekly competitive time windows, limited to weekends, rely on consistent responsiveness. A 30-second cave exit breaks flow. A reused map breaks immersion.
And if future batches follow the same pattern, as early evidence suggests, the model risks fatigue fast. The Switch 2’s broader software rollout remains thin. With no native backward compatibility for most Switch 1 games, and few true next-gen exclusives yet, paid upgrades like this carry outsized weight. They’re supposed to justify the hardware leap.
Right now, this one doesn’t. Nintendo says new Dandori Academy levels drop monthly. The next batch arrives December 1. Whether it addresses the complaints, or doubles down, will tell us whether this is a misstep or a preview of how Switch 2 content will scale.
GDFiled by The Games Desk
Consoles, handhelds, PC gaming and the platforms and hardware behind them.
More from this desk →
Be the first to comment
Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.