Google Maps’ new AI feature, Ask Maps, stumbled in its first real-world trip-planning test — delivering inaccurate pricing, inconsistent business listings, and ignoring core user constraints, while Gemini and ChatGPT produced more reliable, detailed itineraries for the same request. The test, conducted by Android Police and published 22 November 2026, asked three AI tools to plan a weekend trip for someone staying near Millennium Park in Chicago, using only walking and public transit, with strict exclusions: no bars or nightlife, and stops limited to parks, museums, and restaurants.
Each tool was asked to provide opening times, entry prices, directions, and crowd estimates, then adapt the plan for rain (swapping outdoor for indoor locations) and add a coffee stop. All three correctly identified opening hours for major institutions like the Art Institute (11 a.m. Weekends), Field Museum, Chicago Cultural Center, and Chicago Architecture Center.
But accuracy diverged sharply on price and curation. Ask Maps quoted the Chicago Architecture Center at $14, it’s $15. It listed the American Writers Museum at $15, though its website shows $14 online and $16 in person. Gemini matched both figures exactly, including the residency-based pricing tiers at the Art Institute.
ChatGPT also got every verified price right, and went further, calculating a per-person total budget of $163 (excluding lodging and transport), adjusting it automatically when the aquarium replaced an outdoor Sunday stop. Ask Maps’ interface looked polished: numbered stops, embedded map pins, walk-time estimates down to the minute (e.g., “0.3 miles, seven-minute walk”), and one-tap access to save locations or open directions.
But polish didn’t translate to reliability. After the first revision, it replaced the main Field Museum listing, with 4.7 stars and 32,000+ reviews, with a duplicate listing showing just one 5-star review, no opening hours, and no ticket purchase option. It repeated the swap with another duplicate listing featuring two 5-star reviews and the same address but zero operational details.
Worse, it included Sweetwater Tavern & Grille for Sunday lunch, despite the original prompt explicitly banning bars and nightlife. Neither Gemini nor ChatGPT made that error. ChatGPT’s output resembled a printed travel guide: it noted Chicago’s December sunset time (4:20 p.m.), suggested winter clothing, and flagged that the same café appeared twice, then offered alternatives.
Its only minor flaw was repeating a breakfast spot before self-correcting. Android Police concluded it would still use Google Maps to vet individual locations, but avoid Ask Maps for end-to-end planning “for now.” The test doesn’t reflect performance across cities or use cases, only this specific Chicago itinerary under controlled prompts.
No official response from Google has been reported. Ask Maps remains available globally as part of the Google Maps app, with no announced changes to rollout or pricing.
MDFiled by The Mobile Desk
Phones from leak to launch to price cut: what was announced, what it costs where, and when it goes on sale. Indian launches and prices included, not appended.
More from this desk →
Be the first to comment
Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.